Secured vs Unsecured NCDs — What the Charge Actually Gives You
A secured debenture has a charge on the issuer's assets held by a trustee for all holders. Here is what that protection is worth in practice, and why unsecured series pay more.
Most retail NCD issues are secured, some series within them are not, and the difference is priced into the coupon. Understanding what the security actually delivers is the difference between reading that price correctly and assuming the higher number is free money.
What a secured NCD gives you
A charge is created over identified assets of the issuer — for an NBFC, typically its loan receivables — in favour of the debenture trustee, who holds it on behalf of every holder.
Three things follow from that:
- If the issuer defaults, the trustee can enforce the security and apply the proceeds to repaying holders.
- Those assets cannot be freely pledged elsewhere ahead of you.
- The issuer must maintain a stated security cover throughout the tenor, certified to the exchanges every quarter.
That is a real, enforceable improvement over an ordinary unsecured claim.
What it does not give you
It is not a guarantee, and the gap between the legal position and the practical one is worth being honest about.
Enforcement takes time — years, if insolvency proceedings are involved. Asset values at the point of recovery are rarely what the cover ratio suggested when everything was fine, particularly for a lender whose “assets” are loans to borrowers who may also be struggling. And recovery is frequently partial.
Security improves your position substantially. It does not make the instrument risk-free, and treating a secured NCD as equivalent to a bank deposit is the single most common misreading in retail debt.
Security cover, and how to read it
Security cover expresses charged asset value as a multiple of secured debt outstanding. A cover of 1.10 times means the assets behind the debt are worth 110 percent of it.
Two things to check:
- The required cover, stated in the offer document and the trust deed. Higher is better, obviously, but the level is also a signal of what the trustee and the rating agency thought was necessary.
- The type of asset. A charge over a diversified retail loan book behaves very differently in a stress scenario from a charge over a handful of large corporate exposures.
The trustee’s quarterly certificate is filed with the exchanges. It is public, and it is where a deteriorating cover shows up first.
Charge ranking
Two phrases recur in offer documents:
First charge — this debt ranks ahead of other lenders on those assets.
Pari passu charge — it shares equally with other creditors of the same rank. Common, and not a problem in itself, but it means the assets are backing more than just your issue.
The document states which applies. It determines the order of the queue if enforcement ever happens.
Unsecured and subordinated series
Some issues offer an unsecured series alongside the secured ones, usually at the longer tenors and at a higher coupon.
Unsecured means no charge — you are an ordinary creditor, repaid from general cash flows and ranking behind secured lenders.
Subordinated debt, often issued by NBFCs as Tier II capital, goes a step further: it is repaid only after senior creditors have been paid in full. Regulators allow it to count towards capital adequacy precisely because it absorbs losses ahead of other lenders. It carries the longest tenors and the highest coupons in an issue, and it is the riskiest paper on the table.
Reading a mixed issue
A single prospectus can contain secured series at 8.90 percent and an unsecured subordinated series at 9.75 percent. The 85 basis point gap is not a bonus — it is the compensation for giving up the charge and moving behind other creditors.
The practical rule: identify which series you are applying for before you compare coupons across issues. A comparison between one issuer’s subordinated paper and another’s senior secured paper is not a comparison at all.
The question worth asking
Rather than “is this secured?”, ask “how much does the security matter here?”
For a strongly rated issuer with a diversified book, the security is a backstop you will probably never test, and the incremental coupon on unsecured paper may be worth taking.
For a weaker issuer, the security is exactly the thing you are relying on — which means the quality of the charged assets, not the headline cover ratio, is what you are actually buying.
Frequently asked questions
Does 'secured' mean my money is guaranteed?
No. It means there is a legal claim on specific assets if the issuer defaults. Enforcement takes time, asset values at recovery are rarely what they were on paper, and recovery can be partial. It improves your position materially; it does not remove the risk.
What is the difference between a first charge and a pari passu charge?
A first charge ranks ahead of other lenders on those assets. A pari passu charge shares equally with other creditors holding the same rank. The offer document states which applies, and it determines where you stand in a recovery queue.
Why would anyone buy an unsecured NCD?
For the higher coupon, and because the issuer's credit quality may be strong enough that the security makes little practical difference. A AAA-rated issuer's unsecured paper can be a better risk than a lower-rated issuer's secured paper.