🧾 The NCD Guide📐 Structure & Yield
Coupon vs Effective Yield vs YTM — Which Number to Use
The coupon is what the poster advertises. Effective yield is what you earn on a new issue. YTM is what you earn buying on the exchange. Three numbers, three different questions.
Three yield numbers appear around NCDs, they answer different questions, and using the wrong one produces confidently wrong comparisons.
Coupon
The coupon is the annual rate of interest applied to the face value. A 9.50 percent coupon on a 1,000-rupee debenture pays 95 rupees a year, in whatever instalments the series specifies.
It is a contractual term, not a return. It tells you what the issuer pays, not what you earn.
Effective yield
Effective yield annualises the coupon for the timing of payments. It is the figure to use when comparing series within an issue, or comparing two new issues against each other.
The mechanism is straightforward. On a monthly-paying series, the interest you receive in January can be reinvested for eleven months. Compound that across the year and the return exceeds the stated coupon:
| Series | Coupon | Frequency | Effective yield |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual | 9.50% | Once a year | 9.50% |
| Quarterly | 9.20% | Four times | 9.52% |
| Monthly | 9.10% | Twelve times | 9.49% |
The monthly series pays the lowest coupon and delivers almost the same annualised return as the highest. Comparing on the coupon column would have you choose wrongly.
Offer documents publish effective yield for every series. It is a required disclosure, and it is the column to read.
Yield to maturity
YTM is the return implied by the price you actually pay in the secondary market, held to maturity. It combines the remaining coupons with any gain or loss against face value at redemption.
It matters because a listed NCD does not trade at 1,000 rupees. If interest rates have risen since issue, it trades below par; if they have fallen, above.
- Buy a 9.50 percent debenture at 960 and your YTM is above 9.50 percent — you collect the coupon and a gain at redemption.
- Buy it at 1,045 and your YTM is below the coupon, because you take a loss against face value at maturity.
For anyone buying on the exchange rather than in a new issue, YTM is the only number that means anything. The coupon printed on the instrument is almost irrelevant.
Clean price, dirty price and accrued interest
One practical wrinkle when buying listed debentures.
Between coupon dates, interest accumulates day by day. When the debenture changes hands, the buyer pays the seller that accrued interest on top of the quoted price.
- Clean price — what the exchange screen shows, excluding accrued interest
- Dirty price — what actually settles, including it
This is why the debit is larger than the price you saw. It is not a fee; you are buying the interest that has built up since the last payment, and you will receive it at the next coupon date.
It also means comparing two debentures on clean price alone is misleading if they sit at different points in their coupon cycles.
The assumption both yields make
Effective yield and YTM both assume you can reinvest every payment at the same rate. In reality you cannot — that is reinvestment risk, and it bites hardest when rates fall.
The practical implication: a monthly-paying series that looks marginally better on effective yield may not actually deliver that, because the small monthly amounts realistically sit in a savings account rather than earning 9 percent.
For an investor who wants income, choose monthly for the cash flow, not for the yield edge. For an investor who wants compounding and does not need the cash, the cumulative option removes the problem entirely by compounding at the stated rate inside the instrument.
Which number for which question
| Question | Number |
|---|---|
| Which series in this issue pays best? | Effective yield |
| Is issuer A’s new issue better than issuer B’s? | Effective yield, same tenor |
| Should I buy this listed NCD at today’s price? | Yield to maturity |
| What will actually hit my bank account each month? | Coupon on face value |
| How much will be debited for this exchange purchase? | Dirty price |
And one last step that applies to all of them: convert to post-tax before comparing against anything else. Interest is taxed at slab rates, and a 9.5 percent effective yield is closer to 6.6 percent in the highest bracket.
Frequently asked questions
Why is effective yield higher than the coupon on a monthly series?
Because interest received in month one can be reinvested for the remaining eleven months. Annualising that compounding effect produces a figure above the stated coupon. On an annual-payment series, coupon and effective yield are the same.
Should I use YTM or effective yield?
Effective yield when applying to a new issue at face value. YTM when buying a listed debenture on the exchange, because the price you pay is not the face value and that changes your return.
Why is the amount debited higher than the screen price when I buy on the exchange?
Because you also pay the seller the accrued interest since the last coupon date. The screen shows the clean price; the settlement is the dirty price, which includes accrued interest.