🧾 The NCD Guide🛡️ Credit Quality
NCD Credit Ratings — What the Extra Coupon Is Paying For
Every step down the rating scale means a higher coupon and a materially higher chance of trouble. How to read a rating, an outlook, and the security behind a debenture.
Two NCD issues, same tenor, same month. One pays 8.6 percent, the other 10.4 percent. The difference is not generosity — it is the market pricing a difference in the probability of being repaid.
The rating is where that difference is written down.
The scale
Indian long-term ratings run from AAA at the top to D for default, with plus and minus modifiers inside each category:
| Grade | Meaning |
|---|---|
| AAA | Highest safety, lowest credit risk |
| AA | High safety |
| A | Adequate safety |
| BBB | Moderate safety — the lowest investment grade |
| BB | Moderate risk |
| B | High risk |
| C | Very high risk |
| D | In default |
BBB minus and above is investment grade. Below that is speculative, and retail issues rarely go there.
Each step down means a higher coupon. It also means a materially higher historical default rate — the relationship is not linear, and the jump from A to BBB is larger than the jump from AAA to AA.
Reading beyond the letter
Two forward-looking signals sit alongside the rating, and they are frequently more informative:
Outlook — positive, stable or negative — indicates the likely direction over the medium term. A negative outlook on an otherwise comfortable rating is an early warning worth taking seriously, especially if you are considering a long tenor.
Rating watch signals a specific near-term event — an acquisition, a regulatory action, a large refinancing — that may move the rating either way.
The agency also publishes a rationale explaining the rating: what supports it, what constrains it, and what would cause a change. It runs to a few pages and it is the single most useful piece of third-party analysis available on a retail NCD issuer.
The conflict worth knowing about
Rating agencies are paid by the issuers they rate. SEBI manages this through disclosure rules, surveillance obligations and the agencies’ own reputational exposure, but the structure is what it is.
Two practical consequences:
- Read the rationale, not just the letter. The constraints section is where the honest assessment usually lives.
- Where two agencies differ, assume the lower. A split rating between AA minus and A plus is telling you the case is genuinely arguable.
What the security adds
For a secured NCD, the rating already reflects the security. But the details matter separately, because they determine what happens in the bad case:
Security cover — charged asset value as a multiple of secured debt. The offer document states the required level, and the debenture trustee certifies compliance to the exchanges every quarter. Those certificates are public and are where deterioration shows first.
The type of charged asset. A diversified retail loan book behaves very differently under stress from a concentrated corporate exposure, even at identical cover ratios.
The charge ranking. A first charge ranks ahead of other lenders; a pari passu charge shares equally with them.
What actually happens in a default
Worth being concrete, because “secured” can sound like a guarantee.
The payment is missed. The rating drops to D. The debenture trustee is obliged to act for holders — convening them, and pursuing enforcement of the security or insolvency proceedings. Individual holders do not act on their own.
Recovery for secured holders then depends on the quality and enforceability of the charged assets, and it takes years rather than months. Unsecured holders usually recover very little.
None of that is a reason to avoid NCDs. It is a reason to size the position so that a default is disappointing rather than damaging.
A practical rating checklist
- The rating, from each agency that rated the issue
- The outlook, and whether the issue is on rating watch
- The constraints section of the rating rationale
- Whether the series you are choosing is secured or subordinated
- Required security cover, and the type of assets charged
- Any rating history — has the issuer been downgraded before?
The rule that survives everything
A higher coupon is compensation, not a bonus. The market prices credit risk with reasonable efficiency, so an issue paying two percentage points more than its peers is not an oversight.
A portfolio concentrated in high-coupon, low-rated paper is not a high-yield strategy. It is a concentrated bet on a specific credit cycle, and it tends to work for several years and then not.
Frequently asked questions
Is a AA-rated NCD safe?
It indicates high safety and a low probability of default, but it is an opinion, not a guarantee. Ratings are reviewed and can be downgraded, sometimes quickly. AA is meaningfully riskier than AAA, and the coupon gap between them is the market pricing that difference.
Who pays the rating agency?
The issuer. That is a structural conflict, which SEBI manages through disclosure, surveillance requirements and the agencies' own reputational exposure. It is a reason to read the rating rationale rather than just the letter.
What should I do if my NCD is downgraded after I buy it?
First, understand why — the agency publishes a rationale. A downgrade lowers the market price, so selling crystallises a loss. If the issuer is still servicing the debt and you can hold to maturity, holding is often the better option. If the trajectory is deteriorating, that calculus changes.