The Buyback Guide Buyback Basics

Tender Offer vs Open Market — Why Only One Route Remains

SEBI phased out the open market buyback route through stock exchanges. Here is how the two mechanisms differed, why the tender offer won, and what that means for shareholders.

3 min readGuide 2 of 6Updated

Until recently, an Indian listed company had two ways to buy back shares. They produced very different experiences for shareholders, and one of them has been retired.

The tender offer

The company fixes a single price, sets a record date, and gives every eligible shareholder an entitlement proportionate to their holding. A window opens, shares are tendered through the exchange acquisition window, and the company buys.

Its defining features:

  • One price for everyone, normally at a premium to the market
  • Every shareholder on the register participates if they choose to
  • 15 percent of the offer is reserved for small shareholders
  • The outcome is knowable in advance, within limits — you can compute your entitlement the day the record date passes

This is the shareholder-friendly route, and it is now effectively the only one available to listed companies.

The open market route

The company announced a maximum price and a total size, then bought its own shares through ordinary exchange transactions over a period of weeks or months, disclosing daily purchases.

Its features were quite different:

  • No entitlement. You participated only if you happened to sell while the company was buying.
  • No fixed price. The company bought at prevailing market prices, up to a declared ceiling.
  • No reservation for small shareholders.
  • Frequently incomplete. If the price ran above the maximum, the company simply stopped, and announced sizes were routinely left substantially unspent.

For a shareholder, an open market buyback was mostly invisible. It provided some price support and a little extra volume, and that was the extent of the participation for anyone not actively trading.

Why SEBI phased it out

The 2023 amendments to the buyback regulations set a glide path: the ceiling on open market buybacks was cut in stages, disclosure requirements were tightened, and the stock exchange route was discontinued with effect from 1 April 2025.

The stated reasoning covered both problems above.

Unequal treatment. A mechanism where only shareholders who happen to be selling on the right days receive the benefit sits badly next to the principle that a distribution of company cash should reach shareholders proportionately.

Inefficiency. Announced buybacks frequently under-delivered. A company would declare a size, the price would rise past the maximum, and the exercise would end well short — which is a poor way to run a capital return and an unhelpful signal to the market.

What changed for shareholders

Open market Tender offer
Who can participate Whoever is selling at the time Every shareholder on the record date
Price Market price, below a ceiling One fixed price, usually at a premium
Small shareholder reservation None 15 percent
Certainty of completion Low High
Notice you need to take Little The record date matters

The practical effect is that a buyback has become an event you should pay attention to. Under the old route there was often nothing for an ordinary shareholder to do. Under a tender offer there is a record date to be holding on, an entitlement to compute, and a decision to make.

Reading a buyback announcement now

The public announcement is filed with the exchanges and published in newspapers. It carries the route, the price, the total size, the record date and the timetable. Expect it to say tender offer.

From there, three numbers determine everything: the buyback price against the market price, the entitlement ratio once the record date is set, and — only after the offer closes — the acceptance ratio.

The next guides in this book take those in turn.

Frequently asked questions

Why was the open market route phased out?

Two reasons SEBI gave: it treated shareholders unequally, since only those selling at the right moment participated, and it was inefficient — announced buyback sizes were often left substantially unspent because a rising price made the maximum price unreachable.

Can unlisted companies still buy back on the open market?

The SEBI regulations govern listed companies. Unlisted companies operate under the Companies Act alone, which has its own procedure and limits.

Is a tender offer better for a small shareholder?

Considerably. A tender offer reserves 15 percent for small shareholders and gives every eligible holder a proportionate entitlement at a fixed price, usually at a premium. An open market buyback gave a small shareholder nothing unless they happened to sell into it.

Run this process at network scale.

BidFlow handles bulk applications, ASBA form printing, live subscription and GMP data, and one-click allotment checks across every branch.

Book a Demo
Chat with us