🔁 The Buyback Guide📘 Buyback Basics
What Is a Share Buyback, and Why Do Companies Run One?
A buyback is a company using its own cash to purchase and cancel its own shares. Here is what it does to the share count, why boards choose it over a dividend, and what it signals.
A share buyback is a company using its own cash to purchase its own shares from existing shareholders. The shares it buys are cancelled, and the total number in existence falls permanently.
In India this is governed by Sections 68 to 70 of the Companies Act, 2013 and by the SEBI (Buyback of Securities) Regulations, 2018.
What actually happens
Three things, in order:
- The company pays cash to shareholders who choose to sell into the offer.
- Those shares are extinguished — debited from the depository record and cancelled.
- The share count drops, so every remaining share represents a marginally larger claim on the business.
The third point is the one shareholders who do nothing tend to overlook. Not participating is not a neutral act; your proportionate ownership goes up.
Note what cannot happen: Indian companies may not hold bought-back shares as treasury stock and reissue them later. Extinguishment is mandatory, within a prescribed period after settlement.
Why a board chooses a buyback
Surplus cash with nothing better to do. A profitable business generating more cash than it can deploy at a good return has three options: hoard it, distribute it, or waste it. A buyback is one form of distribution.
A view that the stock is cheap. Buying your own shares below intrinsic value transfers value from those who sell to those who stay. Boards say this often; it is true less often.
Improving per-share metrics. Fewer shares means higher earnings per share and higher return on equity, arithmetically. This is real but mechanical, and it says nothing about the underlying business.
Raising promoter holding without buying. If promoters do not tender while the public does, their percentage stake rises as other shares are cancelled. No purchase, no open market activity, higher control.
Supporting a falling price. Less often admitted, occasionally the actual reason.
Buyback versus dividend
Both return cash. They differ in who receives it and who decides.
| Dividend | Buyback | |
|---|---|---|
| Who receives cash | Every shareholder, proportionately | Only those who tender |
| Choice | None — it arrives | Voluntary |
| Effect on share count | None | Permanently reduced |
| Effect on ownership | Unchanged | Non-participants own more |
| Predictability | Often an annual rhythm | Episodic |
The historical argument for buybacks in India was tax: proceeds were exempt in the shareholder’s hands because the company paid a distribution tax. That changed on 1 October 2024. Buyback proceeds are now taxed as deemed dividend in the shareholder’s hands at slab rates, which removed most of the advantage.
That change is significant enough to have its own guide in this book.
What EPS accretion is, and is not
Cancel 5 percent of the shares and earnings per share rises by roughly 5 percent, with no change to the business.
Return on equity rises too, because the equity base shrinks. Both effects are genuine and both will appear in the next quarter’s presentation.
Neither indicates improvement. The company has less cash than it did, and the same operations. Judging a buyback by the EPS bump is like judging a diet by the weight of the clothes you took off.
When a buyback is a bad idea
- Funded by borrowing. Swapping equity for debt at the top of a cycle is leverage, not a return of capital.
- At a stretched valuation. Buying back overvalued shares transfers value to the sellers, from the shareholders who stay.
- Instead of needed investment. Cash returned is cash not spent on the business, and that is only right if the business genuinely cannot use it.
- As price support. It works briefly and it is expensive.
What it means for you as a shareholder
You have a genuine choice, and both answers are defensible.
Tender, and take the premium on whatever portion is accepted — while paying tax on the whole proceeds at your slab rate.
Do nothing, keep your shares, and own a slightly larger share of the company with no tax event at all.
Which is right depends on the price, the acceptance ratio, your view of the business, and your tax position. The following guides take each of those in turn.
Frequently asked questions
Where does the money for a buyback come from?
The company's own free reserves and securities premium, subject to the limits in the Companies Act and the SEBI regulations. A buyback cannot exceed 25 percent of paid-up capital and free reserves, and borrowings after it must not exceed twice that base.
Can the company keep the shares it buys back?
No. Indian law requires bought-back shares to be extinguished within the prescribed period. There is no treasury stock, and they cannot be reissued — which is why a buyback permanently reduces the share count.
Does a buyback mean the stock is undervalued?
It is often presented that way, and sometimes it is true. But a board can be wrong about its own valuation, and a buyback funded from borrowings or launched at a stretched price destroys value rather than returning it.
Do I have to participate?
No. Participation is entirely voluntary. If you do nothing, you keep your shares and your proportionate ownership rises slightly as other shares are cancelled.