The Buyback Guide Tax & Returns

Buyback Taxation After October 2024 — What Changed and Why It Matters

Buyback proceeds are now taxed as deemed dividend in the shareholder's hands at slab rates, and the cost of the tendered shares becomes a capital loss. The full picture.

4 min readGuide 6 of 6Updated

For a decade, buybacks were the tax-efficient way for an Indian company to return cash. The company paid a distribution tax and the shareholder received the proceeds exempt.

That regime ended on 1 October 2024, and the change is large enough that most published advice about buyback arbitrage predates it.

Tax law changes with each Finance Act. This describes the position as at the time of review — confirm the current rules and take professional advice on your own circumstances.

The old regime, briefly

Under Section 115QA, applicable to buybacks before 1 October 2024:

  • The company paid tax at 20 percent plus surcharge and cess on the distributed income
  • The shareholder received the proceeds exempt

For a shareholder in the highest bracket, this was very attractive: a full return of capital plus premium, with no personal tax. It was the central reason buyback arbitrage worked as well as it did.

What applies now

For buybacks completed on or after 1 October 2024:

The entire consideration is a deemed dividend. Section 2(22)(f) treats any payment by a company on the buyback of its own shares as a dividend in the shareholder’s hands, taxable under income from other sources at your slab rate.

No deduction for cost. You are taxed on the whole amount received, not on the gain over what you paid.

The cost becomes a capital loss. Because the sale value is treated as nil, the acquisition cost of the tendered shares is a capital loss, available for set-off against capital gains and carry-forward under the normal rules.

TDS applies. The company deducts at source on the consideration, and you take credit against your final liability.

Section 115QA no longer applies to new buybacks. The company-level tax was withdrawn at the same time.

What that does to the numbers

Take 100 shares bought at ₹1,020, all accepted at ₹1,200, for a taxpayer in the 30 percent bracket.

Under the old regime:

  • Proceeds ₹1,20,000, exempt
  • Cost ₹1,02,000
  • Net gain ₹18,000, tax-free

Under the current regime:

  • Proceeds ₹1,20,000, taxed as dividend at 30 percent: roughly ₹36,000 in tax
  • Capital loss of ₹1,02,000 carried to the capital gains schedule
  • If you have capital gains to absorb that loss, its value is roughly the loss times your capital gains rate
  • If you have no capital gains, the loss is carried forward and is worth nothing this year

The second case is the one to sit with. A trade that showed an ₹18,000 gain can produce a cash outflow in tax that exceeds it, with the offsetting benefit deferred to some future year in which you happen to have capital gains.

The comparison that now matters

Since the change, the relevant question is no longer “tender or hold” but often “tender or sell in the market”.

Tender into the buyback Sell on the exchange
Price Buyback price, at a premium Market price
Taxed on Whole proceeds Gain over cost
Rate Slab Concessional listed-equity rate
Quantity Only the accepted portion Whatever you choose to sell
Loss treatment Cost becomes a capital loss Normal capital gains computation

For a taxpayer in a high bracket with no capital gains to absorb the loss, selling in the market at a lower price can produce a better post-tax outcome than tendering at the premium. That is a genuinely new conclusion, and it is specific to your own tax position.

Who is least affected

Taxpayers in lower slabs. Dividend income at 5 or 20 percent is a much smaller haircut.

Investors with capital gains to offset. The capital loss is immediately useful, which restores much of the arithmetic.

Small shareholders with high acceptance ratios. The premium is large enough on the whole position to survive the tax, particularly where the alternative is selling into a thin market.

The practical steps

  1. Check the completion date. The treatment turns on whether the buyback completed on or after 1 October 2024.
  2. Compute the tax on the full proceeds, not on the gain.
  3. Ask whether you can use the capital loss this year. If not, discount it.
  4. Model selling in the market instead, with the concessional rate, and compare.
  5. Factor in the acceptance ratio, because it determines how much of your position each path actually applies to.

The buyback is still a legitimate way to exit part of a holding at a premium. It is no longer the tax-advantaged instrument it was, and any analysis written before October 2024 is describing a regime that no longer exists.

Frequently asked questions

Am I taxed on the gain or the whole amount?

The whole amount received. Section 2(22)(f) treats any payment by a company on the buyback of its own shares as a dividend in the shareholder's hands, and no deduction is allowed for what you paid for the shares.

What happens to the cost of the shares I tendered?

The sale value is treated as nil, so the acquisition cost becomes a capital loss. It can be set off against capital gains and carried forward under the normal rules — but it is only worth something if you have capital gains to absorb it.

Is TDS deducted?

Yes. The company deducts tax at source on the buyback consideration at the applicable rate, and you take credit for it in your return against your final liability.

Is it now better to sell in the market than to tender?

Often, for a taxpayer in a high bracket without capital gains to absorb the loss. Selling on the exchange produces a capital gain taxed at the concessional listed-equity rate rather than dividend income at slab. Run both, including the premium and the acceptance ratio, before deciding.

Run this process at network scale.

BidFlow handles bulk applications, ASBA form printing, live subscription and GMP data, and one-click allotment checks across every branch.

Book a Demo
Chat with us