📈 The IPO Guide🔍 Analysing an Issue
IPO Red Flags — What Should Make You Walk Away
Every warning sign here is disclosed in the offer document. The problem is not that the information is hidden; it is that almost nobody looks for it.
Every red flag below is disclosed somewhere in the offer document. That is the point. Indian IPO disclosure is genuinely thorough — the failure is almost always on the reading side.
Financial warning signs
Profit without cash
Compare operating cash flow with net profit across three years. A company reporting rising profits while operating cash flow stays negative is recognising revenue it is not collecting, or funding growth through working capital in a way that cannot continue.
This is the single most reliable warning sign in the document, and it is disclosed in the cash flow statement every time.
A spike in the year before the issue
Two flat years followed by a dramatic one, immediately before filing, is a pattern worth interrogating.
Sometimes it is genuine — a new plant commissioned, a large contract won. Sometimes it is deferred costs, pulled-forward revenue, a favourable commodity cycle or a one-off order. The restated financials and the notes will usually tell you which. If you cannot work out where the jump came from, treat the valuation multiple built on it as unsupported.
Receivables outrunning revenue
If revenue grew 30 percent and receivables grew 70 percent, the sales are being made on progressively easier terms — or to customers who are slower to pay. Receivable days are computable from the financials and the trend matters more than the level.
Contingent liabilities against net worth
Disputed tax demands, guarantees given, legal claims. Compare the total against net worth. A contingent liability approaching a material fraction of equity is a risk that has simply not crystallised yet.
Structural warning signs
Related-party revenue
Sales to entities controlled by the promoter are disclosed with amounts. Where they are a material share of revenue, the growth chart is not measuring arm’s-length demand, and the margin may not survive the transactions being unwound.
Promoter selling most of their holding
Check promoter holding before and after the issue. A promoter reducing from 70 percent to 62 percent is normal dilution. A promoter going from 70 percent to 35 percent, in a prospectus describing a decade-long vision, is a tension worth naming out loud.
Proceeds going mainly to repay promoter-related debt
Debt repayment is a legitimate object. Repaying loans taken from, or guaranteed by, promoter entities is a different transaction, and it should be read as such.
An oversized “general corporate purposes” allocation
SEBI caps this precisely because it means the use of funds is undecided. A large allocation to it, next to specific and costed objects, suggests the issue size was set by what the market would absorb rather than by what the business needs.
Governance and history
Regulatory action against promoters or group entities
Read the nature, not the count. Commercial disputes and tax matters are routine. Action for market misconduct, disclosure failures or defaults — particularly across several group entities — is a pattern.
A DRHP that was returned or held in abeyance
Both are public. A returned draft means disclosure was materially incomplete. Abeyance means a legal or regulatory matter was outstanding. Neither prevents a later clearance, and neither stops being relevant once it is granted.
Auditor changes or qualified opinions
A qualification, an emphasis of matter, or a change of auditor close to the filing all warrant reading the surrounding notes carefully.
A very recent restructuring
Subsidiaries merged in, businesses transferred between group entities, or a holding structure created shortly before filing can make the three-year financial history less comparable than it appears. The restatement note will describe what happened.
Issue-level warning signs
Listing under the alternative eligibility route
Companies that do not meet the profitability-based tests must allocate at least 75 percent to QIBs and cap retail at 10 percent. That allocation is disclosed on the cover, and it tells you the company failed the ordinary test before you read anything else.
A peer set that flatters
If the comparables are systematically larger, faster-growing or better-margined, every multiple in the table will make the issuer look cheap. Check who is missing.
A price far above the last private round
The RHP discloses recent transaction prices and the weighted average cost of acquisition for selling shareholders. A very large step-up over a short period needs a business explanation, not a market one.
Very high subscription in a very small issue
Subscription multiples scale inversely with issue size. A tiny issue subscribed 200 times may represent less real money than a large issue subscribed twice, and the multiple is often driven by listing-gain expectations rather than any view on the company.
How to weigh them
None of these is individually disqualifying. Good businesses carry related-party transactions, litigation and lumpy cash flows.
The signal is in the combination. Negative operating cash flow plus a pre-IPO profit spike plus a large promoter OFS plus a premium valuation is not four separate concerns — it is one coherent picture, and it is usually the right one.
If you find two or three from different sections of this list, the base rate says walk away. There is another issue next month.
Frequently asked questions
Is a large offer for sale a red flag?
Not by itself. A financial investor exiting on schedule is routine. It becomes a concern when promoters are selling a large part of their own holding while the prospectus describes a long-term growth plan they are apparently not staying for.
What about a company that has been rejected by SEBI before?
Worth knowing. A returned DRHP means disclosure was materially incomplete; a filing kept in abeyance means a regulatory or legal matter was outstanding. Both are public, and both belong in your assessment even after the issue eventually clears.
How much weight should I put on promoter litigation?
Read the nature of it, not the count. Routine commercial disputes and tax matters are normal in any large business. Regulatory action for market misconduct, or a pattern involving several group entities, is a different category of information.