The IPO Guide Analysing an Issue

IPO Valuation — How to Judge Whether the Price Is Fair

Work out the market capitalisation first, then check the multiples against real peers and against the price paid in recent pre-IPO deals. A practical method that takes about thirty minutes.

4 min readGuide 19 of 26Updated

The most common mistake in IPO analysis is judging an issue by how much it raises. The issue size is the slice being sold. Valuation is about the whole cake.

Step one: compute the market capitalisation

Issue price × total shares outstanding after the issue.

Both numbers are in the RHP: the cap price on the cover, the post-issue share count in the capital structure section. Multiply them.

A company raising 600 crore rupees might be asking the market to value it at 18,000 crore. That 18,000 crore is the number you are agreeing to, and it reframes a surprising number of issues before you have looked at a single ratio.

Then ask the plain question: is this business worth that, next to companies you already know?

Step two: check the earnings behind the multiple

The RHP gives EPS and P/E at both the floor and the cap price. Before using them, check two things.

Pre-issue or post-issue EPS? The fresh issue increases the share count, which mechanically lowers EPS until the new capital starts earning. A P/E computed on pre-issue EPS flatters the valuation. Both are usually disclosed; use the post-issue figure.

Was the last year representative? Look at three years, not one. A profit spike in the year immediately before an IPO is common enough to deserve suspicion — check whether it came from operations or from one-offs, cost deferrals, a favourable commodity cycle or an unusually large single order.

A P/E of 32 on a genuine 30 percent grower is a different proposition from a P/E of 32 on a one-year spike.

Step three: build your own peer set

The RHP’s peer comparison table is the company’s argument. Read it, then construct your own.

Ask whether the comparables match on scale (a 300 crore revenue business against 8,000 crore leaders is not comparable), on margin structure, on growth rate, and on capital intensity. Then check whether an obvious peer is missing — omissions are usually the most informative part of the table.

For each real comparable, pull the current P/E, EV/EBITDA and RoNW from the market. If the issuer is asking for a premium to established peers, there needs to be a reason you can articulate in one sentence.

Step four: use the right multiple for the business

P/E works for stable, profitable companies with a normal capital structure.

EV/EBITDA is fairer for capital-intensive or leveraged businesses, because it looks past interest and depreciation. Enterprise value is market capitalisation plus net debt.

Price to book is the primary lens for banks, NBFCs and insurers, where the balance sheet is the business. Read it alongside RoNW — a lender earning 18 percent on equity deserves a higher multiple than one earning 9 percent.

Revenue multiples are what remain when there are no profits. Use them with a clear view on the path to profitability, and remember that a revenue multiple is a statement about the future rather than a measurement of the present.

Step five: the pre-IPO reference price

This is the check most retail investors never make, and often the most revealing.

The basis for issue price section discloses recent primary and secondary transactions in the company’s shares, and the weighted average cost of acquisition for selling shareholders.

If sophisticated investors bought in at ₹90 eighteen months ago and the band is ₹280 to ₹295, ask what changed. Sometimes the answer is real — profits tripled, a business turned around. Sometimes the only thing that changed is that a retail market became available.

Step six: what growth is the price assuming

You do not need a model. A rough reverse calculation is enough.

If the issue is priced at 45 times post-issue earnings and comparable listed peers trade at 25 times, the market is being asked to pay an 80 percent premium. For that to be reasonable, earnings need to grow substantially faster than the peer group for several years.

Look at the last three years of actual growth and ask whether that is plausible. If the company grew 12 percent a year and the price implies 30 percent for five years, the gap is the risk you are taking.

A thirty-minute checklist

  • Post-issue market capitalisation, computed by hand
  • Post-issue EPS and P/E at the cap price
  • Three-year revenue, profit and margin trend
  • Operating cash flow against net profit
  • RoNW, before and after the issue
  • Two or three peers you selected, with their current multiples
  • Recent pre-IPO transaction price and the weighted average cost of acquisition
  • The one-sentence reason the premium or discount to peers is justified

If you cannot write that last sentence, you do not yet have a view on the price — you have a view on the subscription figures, which is a different thing.

Frequently asked questions

Is a high P/E always bad?

No. A business growing earnings at 30 percent with high returns on capital can deserve a much higher multiple than a slow-growing one. The question is whether the growth implied by the price is achievable, not whether the number is large.

What if the company has no profits?

Then P/E is meaningless and you fall back on revenue multiples, EV/EBITDA where there is positive EBITDA, or unit economics. Loss-making issuers must list under the alternative eligibility route, which caps retail at 10 percent — a signal in itself.

Where do I find the pre-IPO transaction price?

In the basis for issue price section of the RHP, which discloses the price of recent primary and secondary transactions and the weighted average cost of acquisition for selling shareholders.

Run this process at network scale.

BidFlow handles bulk applications, ASBA form printing, live subscription and GMP data, and one-click allotment checks across every branch.

Book a Demo
Chat with us